Please note:
This document is best suited for on-screen use. Some layout may have been
altered during the creation of this web page.
It is recommended that you download the "pdf" version of this
Course Profile for printing and the "Word, Mac, or WordPerfect"
versions for working with or adapting the Course Profile to meet your
instructional needs.
Course Profile
World Religions: Beliefs, Issues, and Religious Traditions, Grade 11, University/College
Preparation, Public
Course Overview
Course
Profiles are professional development materials designed to help teachers
implement the new Grade 11 secondary school curriculum. These materials were
created by writing partnerships of school boards and subject associations. The
development of these resources was funded by the Ontario Ministry of Education.
This document reflects the views of the developers and not necessarily those of
the Ministry. Permission is given to reproduce these materials for any purpose
except profit. Teachers are also encouraged to amend, revise, edit, cut, paste,
and otherwise adapt this material for educational purposes.
Any
references in this document to particular commercial resources, learning
materials, equipment, or technology reflect only the opinions of the writers of
this sample Course Profile, and do not reflect any official endorsement by the
Ministry of Education or by the Partnership of School Boards that supported the
production of the document.
© Queen’s
Printer for Ontario, 2001
Public
District School Board Writing Team – World Religions: Beliefs, Issues, and
Religious Traditions
Lead
Board
Toronto District School Board
Project
Leader
Allan Hux, President OHCA, Toronto District School Board
Writing
Team
Peter McGuinness, Toronto District School Board
Warren Fick, Toronto District School Board
Martha Beaudry, Toronto District School Board
Reviewers
John Myers, OISE/UT
Penny Markopoulos, Toronto District School Board
Beth Hennings, Toronto District School Board
Mary Cunningham, Toronto District School Board
Librarians
Esther Rosenfeld, DWC, Library/Learning Resources, Toronto District School Board
Mark Kaminski, Library consultant, Toronto District School Board
Joanne LaForty, Sir Robert Borden BTI, Toronto District School Board
Associations
Ontario History and Social Studies Teacher Association (OHASSTA)
Ontario History Consultants Association (OHCA)
Course Overview
World Religions: Beliefs, Issues, and Religious Traditions, Grade 11, HRT3M
This
course enables students to discover what others believe and how they live and
to appreciate their own unique heritage. Students learn about the teachings and
traditions of a variety of religions, the connection between religion and the
development of civilization, the place and function of religion in human
experience, and the influence of a broad range of religions on contemporary
society. This course also introduces students to skills used in researching and
investigating world religions.
As
students enter the final two years of high school, they become more aware of
their world, and cognizant of differences and similarities between people. This
expansion of horizons often creates curiosity about what others believe and the
customs and practices which form part of others’ religious observances. In an
increasingly global society, students will encounter people of various
religious backgrounds. A course such as World Religions allows students to
develop some understanding of the ways in which religious traditions affect the
decision-making and way of life of others.
In
this course, the more traditional “historical,” religion by religion, approach
has been abandoned. Instead of studying each religion individually a more
thematic approach is adopted. Examining each religion as an historical
narrative often resulted in students being given extensive detail about matters
in the distant past, rather than being taught much about how the adherents of
the religion are influenced by that belief on a day-to-day basis, in the
contemporary world. In teaching those religions with a lengthy history, being
bound by chronology often resulted in either a disproportionate time being
spent on the study of one religion, or the history of that religion being
truncated. Finally, the approach taken by some teachers in the past is seen by
many as too euro-centric, with the Judeo-Christian viewpoint taken as the norm,
and all others receiving short shrift. All of these are significant objections
to a traditional approach.
On
the other hand, the learning expectations of the policy for this course are
global, rather than specific to one religion, and any attempt to cover a
variety of religions using the strategies of the past might easily become
highly repetitive. Also, due to the global nature of the expectations, these
might possibly be fulfilled by the consideration of only one or two religions
in depth. Since the object of this course is to learn about “a broad range of
religions”, this obviously would violate the policy, in spirit at least. This
course has been designed to address such concerns, as far as is possible.
The
course profile is designed around five thematic units, with the culminating
activity of the course devoted to a student-selected case study of a
significant issue. There are points of contact or similarity between the
themes, but each is distinct enough to be treated separately. Some educators
may feel intimidated by a thematic approach, but this model best addresses the
concerns noted above and suits the needs and interests of students, based on
our experience teaching World Religions. Each unit allows students to examine
the ways in which beliefs, issues, tradition, and practice are entwined. As the
course progresses, students build a repertoire of skills and knowledge that are
needed to undertake the case studies of Unit 6.
Within each unit, the teacher should
select two religions for study. Specific religions have been designated for
each unit in this profile, but factors may dictate that other religions be
substituted for the ones suggested. A list of religions, which lend themselves
to study in particular units, has been included in an appendix. This list is
not exhaustive but presents a good range of possibilities for study. Factors
that influence selection include: the specific knowledge or expertise of the
teacher; the religious profile of the class, the school, or the community; and
the prominence of a given religion in current events, among other things. No
religion should be selected for study in more than two units. This allows as
many as ten different religions to be examined during the course; while it is
not necessary to achieve that number, at least six or seven religions should be
studied, however. In a multicultural and multi-religious society such as
Ontario, this number seems advisable.
It
is important that the teacher create a class atmosphere in which every
religious point of view is treated equitably. Students must be encouraged to
share their own insights, and to respect the views of others, even when
representatives of that religion are not present in class. Activity 1.1 may
help in establishing this atmosphere early in the course. In the past, many
teachers have used the terms major, minor, primitive, etc., to describe
religions; these terms can be seen as pejorative and often give a distorted
impression of the significance or prevalence of individual religions. Such
language should be avoided, and non-judgmental language should always be used.
The particular vocabulary of religious studies should be introduced early, and
reinforced often.
It is
suggested that students be given a brief overview of salient features of each
religion, as it is first introduced in the course. The teacher might prepare
overviews ahead of time, if they are not part of possible texts used in the
class. A synopsis of the central sacred story of each religion should also be
assigned to students, if the story does not form part of the material covered
directly in the unit’s activities.
|
Unit 1 |
Temples
of Wisdom |
12
hours |
|
* Unit
2 |
The
Idea of Deity |
20
hours |
|
Unit 3 |
The
Relationship between Deity and Humanity |
20
hours |
|
Unit 4 |
The
Relationship between Deity and the Individual |
20
hours |
|
Unit 5 |
Person
and Community |
12
hours |
|
Unit 6 |
Case Studies |
26
hours |
* This
unit is fully developed in this Course Profile.
Time: 12 hours
Unit Description
Activity
1.1 should employ brief ethical statements derived from a number of religions (see
Resources) to stimulate students’ understanding. Students or pairs could be
assigned one of these statements and asked to interpret it, assess how it could
be used in daily life, etc. Then interpretations could be shared and a class
discussion developed.
The ways in which human needs are
fulfilled both through relationships with the natural world and with the
supernatural are explored (Maslow’s hierarchy of needs might provide a
framework for this discussion). The connection between individual and community
needs should also be explored using an organizer, or similar technique. The
nexus between our need, desires, and vulnerability to events beyond our control
is examined in a jigsaw activity using First Nations, Aboriginal, or Animistic
spirituality as an example. Different roles of religion are considered, and
students are called on in a “fishbowl” lesson to defend one or more of the
roles. At this point the teacher might tie the introductory activity to the
discussion of the roles of religion, e.g., that humans are themselves part of a
natural world and that ethical treatment of each other is a vital subset of
ethical relationships with the rest of creation.
(Note:
Activity 1.1 should be a stand-alone introduction, if a teacher decides to use
a different unit as the first unit of study.)
Unit
Overview Chart
|
Act. |
Expectations |
Assessment |
Focus/Activity |
|
1 |
RBV.02,
HEV.01, RB2.01 |
Thinking Understanding |
Ethics: analysis of the “golden rules” |
|
2 |
RBV.01,
HE1.02, HE4.02 |
Inquiry Knowledge |
Individual
and community needs explored: organizer |
|
3 |
RBV.03,
RB1.01, HEV.01, HEV.02, IS2.04 |
Application Understanding |
How
religions are created to fulfill human needs: the impact of events beyond our control -
jigsaw |
|
4 |
RB2.01,
HEV.02, HE1.02, IS2.03 |
Inquiry Application Knowledge |
Roles
of religion: fishbowl lesson/defending an argument |
|
5 |
SS1.04,
SS1.05, ISV.05, ISV.06, IS1.04, IS1.06, IS2.05 |
Inquiry Application Understanding Communication |
Holy places,
Holy rites |
Culminating
Activity
Students
research and express their understanding of a religion’s holy places or sacred
rites. This activity invites visual, kinesthetic, and sensory learners to
perform at a high level. For example, students create a visual representation
of a Mayan temple, Shinto shrine, etc. and explain how this structure relates
to the individual/social needs and religious belief of the people who built it.
Or, students research the sacred Mayan Ball game and demonstrate to the class
how it was played using the school gymnasium as the court. (This might be a
cross-curricular assignment with Physical Education.). Students should be given
an opportunity to peer-assess their classmates’ efforts, using a
teacher-generated rubric.
Time: 20 hours
Unit
Description
This unit is the most complex and is
explored in detail as the sample unit. Students explore how two radically
different religions view the concept of deity. The first sub-unit (2.1-2.3) considers
Zoroastrianism. While this is a monotheistic religion it is sufficiently
different from Judeo-Christian beliefs to stimulate students’ thoughts about
the constituents of a monotheistic religion. The second sub-unit (2.4-2.6)
deals with Hinduism. The teacher should emphasize that, within a polytheistic
belief system, monism can thrive. If the teacher so desires, some other
representative monotheistic and polytheist religions may be compared. The
Internet should be introduced as an aid in studying World Religions, during
this unit. (Note: Unit 2 is fully developed in this profile.)
Unit
Overview Chart
|
Act. |
Expectations |
Assessment |
Focus/Activity |
|
1 |
RB1.01,
RB2.10, SSV.01, HE4.01 |
Understanding |
Good
and Evil: compare and contrast |
|
2 |
RBV.03,
RB2.04, RB2.09, ISV.05, ISV.06 |
Communication |
One
Single God: Ahuramazda’s role organizer |
|
3 |
RB1.04,
RB2.01, RB2.02, RB2.03 |
Knowledge |
The
Role of the Amesha Spentas and Yazatas: report |
|
4 |
RBV.01,
RB1.01, RB1.02, RB1.03, RB2.09, RB2.10, SS1.03, HEV.01, HE1.01, HE3.02,
HE4.01, HE4.02, ISV.06, 1S1.06 |
Knowledge Application Thinking/
Inquiry |
Hinduism
– The Endless Cycle: case studies (biographies) |
|
5 |
RB2.02.
RB2.03, HEV.04, HE3.01, IS1.04 |
Understanding |
Messengers,
Avatars, Incarnations: compare and contrast |
|
6 |
RB2.01,
RB2.05, RB3.03, SSV.02 |
Thinking |
The
Portrayal of Deity in Art and Poetry: analysis |
|
7 |
RBV.02,
ISV.02, RB2.02, BR2.04, HE2.02, IS1.01 |
Thinking/
Inquiry Application Understanding |
“Recipe”
for a Religion |
Culminating
Activity
Students
create a “recipe” or “formula” for religion, taking into account the several
different approaches to spirituality examined so far in the course. They then apply
this “recipe” to a sample religion to see if it meets the criteria established.
Brainstorming and class discussion are used to create a list of five to ten
essential “ingredients” (e.g., has a divinity or divinities; has a basic code
of conduct or ethics; has an explanation for creation, etc.). Students generate
an organizer and, using materials supplied by the teacher, examine Jainism to
see how well it fits the “recipe.” Jainism specifically should be used, since
it may challenge some preconceptions students have. In a final report they
explain how it did or did not meet expectations, and draw a conclusion about
the usefulness of preconceived ideas when dealing with religion.
Time: 20 hours
Unit Description
This
unit examines the different ways in which religions have seen the connection
between deity and human beings. Judaism and Islam are considered and a contrast
is drawn between concepts of this relationship as based on a covenant, and as
based on submission. The unit is divided into sub-units on Judaism (3.1-3.4),
and Islam (3.5-3.8). There are major activities at the end of each sub-unit.
The Internet should be used as a research tool in this unit whenever the
opportunity presents itself, and certainly in section 3.8. Section 3.9 includes
the unit culminating activity and synthesizes the material covered in the two
sub-units. Learning activities in this unit invite visual, kinesthetic, and
sensory learners to perform at a high level.
The
Judaism sub-unit gives opportunities to examine primary and secondary materials
and to use debating, dramatic, and kinesthetic skills to present the student’s
findings. The history and impact of the idea of the Covenant are traced and
presented graphically.
Unit
Overview Chart - Judaism Sub-unit
|
Act. |
Expectations |
Assessment |
Focus/Activity |
|
1 |
RBV.02,
RBV.03, RBV.04, RB1.03, RB1.04, RB2.04, RB2.06, RB3.02, HE3.01, ISV.06,
IS1.04 |
Thinking Understanding Communication |
The Sacred
Story - the sacrifice of Abraham in Judaism and Islam: debate |
|
2 |
RBV.01,
RBV.04, RB2.08, RB2.06, HEV.01, IS1.04 |
Inquiry Knowledge |
One
Type of Relationship: The Covenant: chart/timeline |
|
3 |
RBV.04,
RB2.06, RB3.02, IS1.04 |
Application Understanding |
The
Connection between Sacred Writings and Practice: re-enactment of Passover or Purim |
|
4 |
RBV.01,
RB1.04, RB2.09, SSV.01, HEV.01, HE4.03, ISV.01, ISV.06, IS1.04, IS1.05,
IS2.02 |
Thinking Knowledge/
Understanding Communication |
Breach of
Promise - does God keep the Covenant?: mock trial/report |
Sub-unit
Culminating Activity: 3.4
Where
is God when He is needed? Students, having developed some understanding of the
relationship between God and the Jews being based on a covenant, are asked to
consider whether God’s side of the bargain has been kept. The teacher should
introduce readings from the Book of Job or material from the Jewish “Death of
God” movement and divide the class into plaintiff and defendant legal teams and
a jury. After both sides have presented their cases, the summations and jury’s
decision are presented as written reports. Students, with teacher assistance,
should be given the opportunity to develop a rubric for assessing the
presentation.
Students
are given an opportunity to learn about prejudice and stereotypes and to use
research as a method to refute them, as they explore Islam. The origins and
spread of this religion are highlighted using poetry and historical documents
well as other (secondary) sources. The Five Pillars are explored, and students
develop a presentation based on one of them.
Unit
Overview Chart - Islam Sub-unit
|
Act. |
Expectations |
Assessment |
Focus/Activity |
|
5 |
SSV.01, SS1.02, SS1.07, HEV.02, HE2.02,
ISV.03 |
Inquiry Understanding |
Identifying Images of Islam: organizer |
|
6 |
RBV.01, RB1.03, RB2.06, HE3.02, SSV.02,
SS1.01, SS1.03, SS1.02 |
Knowledge Communication |
The Origins and Growth of Islam: map/timeline/poetry
analysis |
|
7 |
RB3.02,
ISV.O5, IS1.04, IS1.05 |
Thinking Application Communication |
The
Five Pillars – Submission to God’s Will: presentation |
|
8 |
SSV.01,
SSV.O4, SS1.07, HEV.02, HE2.02, ISV.03, IS1.05 |
Thinking Application Knowledge |
Images
Reconsidered: research assignment |
|
9 |
RBV.02,
RB2.09, SSV.04, SS1.02, HE3.02, HE4.03 |
Understanding Communication |
Covenant
and Submission Compared: short essay |
Sub-unit
Culminating Activity: 3.8
Students select
one or two of the images of Islam generated in 3.5 and, using their class notes
and further research, attempt to discover what lies behind this perception. The
learning here should come from students’ discoveries, not from teacher input. A
rubric could be developed which allows students to score well for their
research skills and summation of the material, not on their success in proving
or disproving the image. Peer assessment could be used as a component of the
activity.
Unit
Culminating Activity: 3.9
Students
write a (750- to 1500-word, depending on the academic strengths of the class)
argumentative essay on their perception of the benefits or obstacles to a
community of a relationship with Deity based on Covenant or Submission.
Time: 20 hours
Unit
Description
This unit
gives students the opportunity to examine the sources of religious beliefs,
sacred texts, myths, and stories in greater depth and to come to an
understanding of the meaning of key concepts, such as salvation and religious
codes of conduct. Through the research and performance of a religious ritual,
students demonstrate their understanding of the reasons for rituals and the
various ways in which various religions communicate with the divine. Thus the
connection between religious beliefs and individual actions in one’s daily life
is further reinforced. Learning activities in this unit invite visual,
kinesthetic, and sensory learners to perform at a high level.
Unit Overview
Chart
|
Act. |
Expectations |
Assessment |
Focus/Activity |
|
1 |
RB1.04, RB2.09, RB2.10 |
Thinking Knowledge |
The Meaning of Salvation: compare/contrast |
|
2 |
RB2.10, SS1.07, HE1.01, HE3.01, HE3.02 |
Inquiry Understanding |
Religious Ethics and Religious Role Models: research assignment |
|
3 |
RB3.02, HE4.01, ISV.04, ISV.06, IS1.03 |
Inquiry Communication |
Deity in the Daily Lives of Individual
Adherents: interview/report |
|
4 |
RBV.04,
RB3.02, RB3.03, SS1.07, HE4.01, ISV.04, ISV.06, IS1.06 |
Inquiry Application Understanding |
Rituals,
Worship, and Lifestyle: performance/re-enactment |
|
5 |
RBV.02,
RBV.03, RBV.04, RB1.04, RB2.09, RB2.10, RB3.02, RB3.03, SSV.03, SS1.04, SS1.07,
HEV.01, HEV.03, HE1.01, HE3.01, HE4.01, ISV.05, IS1.06 |
Thinking Application Knowledge Communication |
“The
Religious Game of Life”: design of a board game |
Culminating
Activity
Students research
the relationship between deity and the individual in a selected religion and
use their knowledge and skill to create a board game. The object of the game is
for the adherent to live her/his life by the code of conduct for the chosen
religion. The board must reflect modern society, and the game must be designed
so the players face realistic moral/ethical challenges (the result of a class
brainstorm). The board should demonstrate students’ understanding of the key
concepts in the religion, sacred text or stories, knowledge of role models, the
code of conduct, knowledge of sacred rituals and forms of worship, connecting
with the unseen world, and the “ultimate goal” of the adherents. It is strongly
suggested that teachers devote 45 minutes of class time in directing students
in the development of a rubric, which will be used to evaluate this activity.
This will enable students to further develop their self-assessment skills and
clearly define performance expectations.
Time: 12 hours
Unit
Description
An
individual who practises a given religion has many complex interactions with
her/his religious community. They provide the background against which many of
life’s key moments are lived. In this unit, students examine what constitutes a
community, the roles necessary for a fully functioning community life, how
“belonging” to a particular community is expressed, and the effect of community
expectations on the individual in regard to gender roles and milestones such as
marriage and divorce. They also examine their own community and compare it to
others in Ontario to see how the mix of religious affiliations can vary from
place to place, and from year to year.
Unit
Overview Chart
|
Act. |
Expectations |
Assessment |
Focus/Activity |
|
1 |
RB1.02, RB1.04, RB2.01, RB2.02, RB3.01,
RB3.O3, SSV.04, SS1.08, HEV.02, HE1.01, ISV.05, ISV.06 |
Thinking Understanding |
What Makes a Community?: analysis |
|
2 |
RBV.01, RB1.02, SSV.01, SS1.01, SS1.03, HEV.04,
HE1.03, ISV.04, IS1.01, IS1.02, IS1.05, IS2.02 |
Inquiry Knowledge Communication |
Religious Affiliation in Ontario Communities: compare/contrast
small and large centres, and one centre over time |
|
3 |
RB1.05,
RB2.01, SS1.02, SS1.03, HEV.01, HE2.04, HE4.01, HE4.03, IS1.01, IS1.04,
IS1.06, IS2.04 |
Application Understanding |
Belonging
- how issues such as marriage outside the community can effect adherents of a
religion: research |
|
4 |
BRV.03,
RB1.02, RB1.04, SSV.03, SS1.07, HE2.02, HE2.03, HE3.03, ISV.05, ISV.06,
IS1.02, IS1.04, IS1.05, IS2.04 |
Knowledge/ Communication |
Women
and Men - gender roles and religious communities: debate |
Culminating
Activity
The teacher
introduces the topic of gender roles and religion by doing a word association
with the class and highlighting the patterns of gender bias, which emerge. The
class should discuss where such stereotypes come from (e.g., scripture,
religious tradition, social conventions, etc.). Two or more questions for
debate should also be proposed and pro and con sides should be assigned.
Students research their positions and present their cases using strict
timelines. Following closing arguments, the audience can be polled for their
decision as to which side won the debate. The debate should be evaluated using
a rubric that is informed by awareness of the informal logical fallacies, which
should be explained to students prior to the debate.
Time: 26 hours
Unit
Description
Religion
often serves as a nexus in conflict. Understanding of how religion affects
issues in society is developed through case studies. Three sample case studies are
introduced and taught separately by the teacher, with materials supplied to
students. Students are shown how to analyse the information they research,
create a thesis, map out an argument to support a thesis, and synthesize the
results of these activities into a final presentation and report. Upon
completion of the introductory activities in this unit, students are well
prepared to both identify and investigate a critical issue in World Religions.
Activities 6.1-6.3 lead into the culminating activity for the whole course
(6.4).
Unit
Overview Chart
|
Act. |
Expectations |
Assessment |
Focus/Activity |
|
1 |
RBV.03, BRV.04, RB1.05, RB2.06, RB2.10,
SSV.03, SSV.04, SS1.01, SS1.02, SS1.03, SS1.07, HE1.01, HE2.02, HE4.01,
ISV.06, IS1.05, IS2.04 |
Thinking Understanding |
Divorce in the Jewish Community - the Great
Agunah Debate: evaluation and
analysis |
|
2 |
RB1.01, RB1.04, RB2.04, RB2.06, RB2.09,
RB2.10, SS1.08, HEV.03, HEV.04, HE1.02, HE2.01, HE4.04, 1SV.01, ISV.02,
ISV.05, IS1.04, IS1.05, IS2.03, IS2.04 |
Inquiry Knowledge |
Creationism and Science – ever since Scopes: thesis statement and
outline of argument |
|
3 |
RB1.02, RB1.03, RB3.03, SSV.04, SS1.02,
HEV.04, IS 1.01, IS1.04, IS2.04, IS2.05 |
Thinking Application Knowledge Communication |
The Sikh Community in Conflict: multi-paragraph
essay |
|
4 |
RB1.02,
RB1.03, RB1.04, RB3.03, SSV.04, SS1.02, HEV.04, ISV.01, ISV.O3, ISV.05,
IS1.01, IS1.04, IS2.01, IS2.02, IS2.04 |
Thinking/Inquiry Application Knowledge/
Understanding Communication |
Individual
Case Study: position paper/ |
Culminating
Activity
Students
work in pairs to identify a socio-religious issue of current significance. They
thoroughly investigate this issue, using research methodologies appropriate to their
case study, and write an individual position paper in which they outline their
findings, select an approach, which could be taken to resolve the issue, and
defend their solution. Finally, students communicate their findings using a
storefront display in a “Critical Issues in World Religions Forum.” This format
allows students to communicate their specific case study findings while
gathering information on a variety of other case studies. Students, with
minimal teacher input, should develop a rubric for peer assessment of the
storefront display component of the activity; each display should be assessed
by at least two students, and each student should be responsible for assessing
two displays by his/her peers. Completion of these assessments should be included
in the overall mark for the activity.
Teachers
use a variety of teaching/learning strategies in presenting this course.
Although this subject is weighted toward the written word, a major concern has
been that sufficient learning activities be presented to enable visual,
kinesthetic, and sensory learners to perform at a high level. As designed, this
course provides an excellent opportunity for students to develop intelligences
on multiple levels. Overall, students should be encouraged to think critically,
work cooperatively, conduct research using both primary and secondary sources,
and synthesize rational positions.
In
Unit 1 students begin to learn the vocabulary of religious studies and to
employ it in small group and class discussions. Jigsaws and organizers can be
used to investigate the relationship between human needs, the natural world,
and supernatural agencies.
In
Unit 2 students employ compare and contrast skills; audio-visual and multimedia
materials can be used to enrich their understanding of the portrayal of deity.
In
Unit 3 debates, re-enactments, and mock trials give several opportunities for
students to develop and employ their subject vocabulary. Map exercise and
timelines increase visual learning, and poetry analysis should stimulate
non-linear thinking.
In Unit 4, person-to-person interviews and
performance/re-enactments are employed, as well as skills in visual
presentation and conceptualization (rules of play, design of game, etc.).
In
Unit 5 numeric/statistical analysis is employed. Debates here deepen analytical
ability and stimulate logical processing.
Throughout,
frequent use is made of brainstorming, fishbowl discussion, and problem
solving, etc., as indicated. Guest speakers, audio-visual materials, field
trips, Socratic lessons, and guided Internet searches, should be used as
appropriate, to make the material more accessible.
Teachers
should use regular formative quizzes as an aid to students, allowing them to
check how well they have assimilated the factual content presented in each
unit.
In order
for the peer assessment element of the course culminating activity to be
successful, students should be given several opportunities, in various units,
to assist in developing rubrics that will be used to evaluate their work.
Assessment
and evaluation in this course are based on the Achievement Chart categories
found in The
Summative
assessment of the final culminating activity comprises 30% of the overall
course evaluation. The performance expectations of each unit are directly
connected to the performance criteria in the culminating activity in regard to
all areas of the Achievement Chart. For example:
In
Unit 1, students explore the origins and implications of religious inspiration,
human needs, and religious goals. Skills emphasized in this unit include note
taking, discussion, organization of information, and the proper use of
religious terminology. Of critical importance in this unit is the focus on
defending an argument in Activity 1.4.
In
Unit 2, students learn to interpret source documents and to extrapolate
religious doctrine from them. Their understanding of religious terminology is
extended through discussion of the critical topics of monotheism and
polytheism. Students expand their skills in organizing important information,
comparing and contrasting abstract concepts, analysis, and report writing. In
Activity 2.4, case studies are first introduced to ensure students have
familiarity with them when the culminating activity is reached.
In
Unit 3, students are introduced to key concepts regarding the relationship
between human beings and deity. The importance of exploring the historical
origins of religious belief and practice is underlined. Skill in using primary
(sacred texts) and secondary (commentaries and interpretations) materials is
applied and enhanced. More use is made of the Internet, and students should be
given criteria to evaluate the appropriateness of this material.
In
Unit 4, students are asked to make the connection between religious beliefs and
individual actions in daily life. Research methods are further developed with
the introduction of oral interviews. Emphasis is placed on creatively
communicating the results of inquiry. The culminating activity enables students
to develop their visual presentation skills and apply their research findings
to a modern setting.
In
Unit 5, the concept of community is explored, and some of the ramifications of
being an individual within a broader community are examined. There is more use
of primary materials and statistical analysis is introduced, broadening the
possible avenues of research methodology students might employ in the
culminating activity.
Finally,
in Unit 6, three case studies are broached and investigated collectively to
give students a chance to develop greater familiarity with this approach to
studying a religion. The activities associated with Activities 6.1-6.3 help
students refine in detail the skills and techniques necessary to tackle the
culminating activity.
In preparing this profile,
assignments have been suggested for all units rather than summative tests.
However, teachers may choose to substitute up to two summative tests for unit
assignments, if constraints of time, etc., make this necessary. It should be
noted that no exam is envisaged for this course. The culminating activity is,
of itself, an authentic performance of students’ learning throughout the
course.
Seventy
per cent of the grade will be based on assessments and evaluations conducted
throughout the course. Thirty per cent of the grade will be based on a final
evaluation in the form of an examination, performance, essay, and/or other method
of evaluation.
The study
of world religions is a textual study, in the main. This presents a significant
barrier to achievement if students have specific learning disabilities, such as
dyslexia and dysgraphia, or where English is the student’s second language. The
teacher should refer to the student’s IEP (Individual Education Plan) when
considering accommodations. Individualized accommodations are included in each
student’s IEP, which should provide an excellent source of strategies to deal
with learning exceptionalities. Some possible accommodations include:
·
Student
reading comprehension level should be assessed early.
·
A
range of materials should be offered in any language-based activity (e.g.,
Activity 4.1).
·
Whenever
possible, vocabulary lists should be made available.
·
Context
clues and related vocabulary should be discussed.
·
·
Teachers
should model through skills when expecting students to draw inferences,
conclusions, or assess the implications of case study material (e.g., Activity
2.6).
·
Main
ideas and new information should be mapped out and organized via charting,
blocking, graphing, categorization, paraphrasing, and highlighting (e.g., 2.1).
·
ESL
students may benefit from being allowed to prepare their arguments for debate
(e.g., Activity 3.1) or mock trial (e.g., Activity 3.4) in their first
language.
·
ESL
students may need support in completing peer assessments.
·
Students
with visual impairment may need alternate assignments for activities involving
graphic representations (e.g., Activity 3.3).
·
Students
with significant motor dysfunction (e.g., cerebral palsy) may need adjustments
in performance-based components (e.g., Activities 1.5, 4.4).
·
A
slow rate of speech, pausing frequently in a natural way, should be modelled
for activities requiring oral presentations (e.g., Activity 3.4).
·
The
ability to criticize constructively and accept constructive criticism should be
discussed with students, and modelled, before peer-evaluation exercises are
attempted (e.g., Activity 1.5).
·
Open-ended
activities should be provided whenever possible.
·
Alternate
units beyond the regular curriculum could be made available.
This is
not an exhaustive list and teachers could ensure the religions covered include
as many alternatives as possible, depending on class, school, or community
religious profile. Distinct religions and sects exist within many of these
categories, but are not explicitly listed here in each case. The teacher should
endeavour to be as specific as possible in choosing religions to teach,
wherever possible, e.g., Yoruba Religion, not just “African”; Theravada, not
just “Buddhism”; Anabaptism, or even Amish, rather than “Christianity.”
Unit 1: Native North American Spirituality, Mayan
religion, Aboriginal Religions, Animism, Shintoism, Wicca/Neo-paganism,
Jainism, Zoroastrianism.
Unit 2: Zoroastrianism, Judaism, Hinduism, Ancient
Paganism, African Religions, Jainism, Shakerism, Rastafarianism, Mormonism,
Theravada Buddhism.
Unit 3: Judaism, Islam, Mahayana Buddhism, Ancient
Paganism, Zoroastrianism, Eastern Orthodoxy, Reformation Protestantism,
Baha’ism, and Mormonism.
Unit 4: Recent Protestantism, Hinduism, Orthodox
Judaism, Baha'ism, Sikhism, African religions, Wicca/Neo-paganism.
Unit 5: Sikhism, Amish/Mennonite/Anabaptism, Shintoism,
Rastafarianism, Mormonism, Animism, African religions, Judaism, Roman
Catholicism, Islam, Zoroastrianism.
Books
Atlas of the World’s Religions.
A good source for giving some idea of the scope of various religions.
Vignettes of the life of Muslim women.
Breitowitz,
Irving A. Between Civil and Religious Law.
Greenwood Publishing Group, 1993
ISBN 0313284717
Deals with Jewish laws regarding marriage and the difficulties faced by
individuals without a Get.
Breuilly,
This excellent resource presents each religion in up-to-date language and
images. Glossary.
Ellis,
Marc H. Unholy
ISBN 0800630807
The Encyclopaedia of Man, Myth and
Magic: The Illustrated Encyclopaedia of Mythology, Religion and the Unknown. Vol. 1-21. Marshall Cavendish,
1995. ISBN 1122083092
This encyclopaedia covers in depth the religions of the world, the myths of
mankind, and the supernatural. Wonderful illustrations.
The Encyclopaedia of Women and World
Religion. Two
volumes. Prentice-Hall
ISBN 0028646088
Comparative study of religious issues such as mythology, ordination, afterlife;
also includes the study of art in religion, literature, and science;
biographies of religious leaders.
Freke,
Timothy. Encyclopaedia of Spirituality:
Information and Inspiration go Transform Your Life.
Divided into three sections: spiritual traditions, which cover ancient
religions to new age, spiritual practices, and Spiritual teachings. Shows links
between traditional religion and new movements.
Harlan,
Lindsey, and Paul B Courtright, eds. From
the Margins of Hindu Marriage: Essays in Gender, Religion, and Culture.
Haynes,
Stephen R. and John K. Roth, eds. The
Death of God Movement and the Holocaust: Radical Theology Encounters the Shoah.
The challenges posed by the Holocaust to Jewish theology spawned this movement
(useful for Unit 3).
Jacobs,
William Jay. Great Lives: World Religions.
ISBN 0684197030
Brief biographies of religious leaders from ancient religions to the present.
Very readable for students.
Kinsley,
David R. Hinduism: A Cultural
Perspective, 2nd ed.
Prentice Hall, 1993. ISBN 0-1339-5732-2
Kolitz,
Zvi. Yossel Rakover Speaks to God:
Holocaust Challenges to Religious Faith. Ktav Publishing House, 1995. ISBN
0881255262
Matthews,
Peter and Linda Schele. The Code of
Kings: The Language of Seven Sacred
Matthews,
Reader Ian. A Simple Guide to Shint.
Tallman Company, 1997. ISBN 1-8603-4003-2
Nelson,
John K. A Year in the Life of a Shinto
Shrine.
ISBN 0-2959-7500-8
John
Bowker. The
A comprehensive and authoritative reference work. Highly recommended as a
teacher resource.
Philip,
Neil. Myths and Legends: Annotated Guides.
Beautiful book combines world myths and legends with painting, artefacts, and
concise annotation.
Prime,
Ranchor. Hinduism and Ecology - Seeds of
Truth. Cassell Publishers Ltd., 1992.
ISBN-0-304-32313
Smith,
Huston. The Illustrated Worlds Religions:
A Guide to Our Wisdom Traditions. Harper-Collins, 1994. ISBN 0060674407
A renowned authority on the subject of world religions.
Tanakh, Student Edition. Jewish Publication Society, 1991.
ISBN 0-8276-03665
A good edition of the Jewish Bible, suitable for use by students.
Tedlock,
Dennis, trans. Popul Vuh: The Mayan Book
of the Dawn of Life. Simon and Schuster, 1996. ISBN 0-6848-1845-0
A good translation of the Mayan story of creation. A good source for
information on the Sacred Ball Game.
Thomas,
David. Marriage & Life Choices: The
Catholic Experience. Glencoe/MacMillan McGraw Hill, 1993. ISBN 0026559110
Series
Oneworld Series
Scholarly look at
each religion, which includes the schools of thought, doctrines, and practices.
May be difficult for students with low reading skills. A good teacher resource.
Cohn-Sherbrok. Judaism: A Short Introduction. Oxford,
England: Oneworld, 1999. ISBN 1851682074
Klostermaier,
Klaus. Buddhism: A Short Introduction.
Oxford, England: Oneworld, 1999.
ISBN 1851681868
(There
are other books in this series)
Videos
Beyond the Veil. CBC, 1996.
Correspondent Anna-Marie Tremonti spoke to Islamic women about gender issues in
their religion.
Faith & Belief: Five Major World
Religions.
Knowledge unlimited, 1992.
This video compares and contrasts five different world religions.
Five Pillars of Islam. R.M. Productions, 1988.
God @ heaven.com: Is God in
cyberspace? High
tech culture series #03, Omni Film Production, 1995.
Religious leaders from six different faiths address questions about sin and
salvation on-line.
How Beliefs and Values Define a
Culture. Duncan
Landaas Ltd, McIntrye, 1997.
This explores how religion and other elements define a culture.
Lord of the Dance. Thirteen-WNET, 1993.
The Hindu creation myth is presented. A look at sacred and secular dance.
The Spirit of Tibet: Journey to
Enlightenment, the Life, and World of Dilgo Khyentse Rinpoche.
National Film Board, 1998.
The fascinating story of Dilgo Khyentse Rinpoche, one of Tibet’s spiritual
leader.
The Spirit Within. National Film Board, 1989.
Native prisoners learning about their spiritual roots from their elders.
Holy Land, Holy People Series
“The Children of
Abraham.” Villagers Media Production in association with Vision TV, 1997.
Jews, Muslims, and Christians share the same God. This film traces the
spiritual roots of each religion.
“Covenant and Reality.” Villagers Media Production in association with Vision
TV, 1997.
This film examines the struggles of people who live in accordance with
religious ideals.
“The Desert.” Villagers Media Production in association with Vision TV, 1997.
Role of the desert in these three religions is explored.
(Other titles are available in this series)
Religions Of The World Series
Ben Kingsley
narrates this series that covers history, founding leader(s) and cultural
influences.
“African and African-American Religions.” Liberty International Entertainment,
1998.
“Ancient Religions of the Mediterranean.” Liberty International Entertainment,
1998.
“Native American Spirituality.” Liberty International Entertainment, 1998.
“Religions of Small Societies.” Liberty International Entertainment, 1998.
(Other titles are available in this series)
Websites
Note: The URLs for the websites have been
verified by the writers prior to publication. Given the frequency with which
these designations change, teachers should always verify the websites prior to
assigning them for student use.
Encyclopaedia
Mythica – http://www.pantheon.org/mythica/
On-line encyclopaedia of mythology folklore and legend. Hard to beat as a quick
source for student use.
Gender
equality in Islam – http://www.mwlusa.org/pub_gender.shtml
Deals with issues involving the role of women in the Muslim community: divorce,
human rights, etc.
Ontario
Consultants on Religious Tolerance – http://www.religioustolerance.org/
One of the best sources for unbiased information about various religions
available on the Internet.
Patterns
of Religious Attendance – http://www.statcan.ca/english/indepth/indepth.htm
A PDF file from Statistics Canada’s In-Depth
magazine, Winter 2000. Useful for Activity 5.2; Statistics Canada also has
material on the religious breakdown of many Ontario communities.
Religion
and Philosophy – http://www.digital-librarian.com/religion.html
A list of links that relate to all aspects of world religions.
World
religion resources – http://www.refdesk.com/factrel.html
This site links to 116 sites related to all different religions. Very
comprehensive.
Other
The
Traveling World Religions, which is organized from Guelph, is an excellent
resource.
The speaker provides much visual material along with superb commentary.
Contact Larry Windland, tel: 519-822-4150, fax: 519-822-1230, e-mail:
lwindland@rlds.ca
Coded Expectations, World Religions: Beliefs, Issues, and Religious Traditions, Grade 11, University/College Preparation, HRT3M
RBV.01 · summarize the major historical influences
on and events in the development of various religions;
RBV.02 · analyse the similarities and
differences between the central beliefs of various religions;
RBV.03 · analyse and describe the
connection between the human experience and sacred writings and oral teachings;
RBV.04 · demonstrate how practice, ritual,
and symbolism are external representations of the beliefs and principles of
religion.
Historical
Background
RB1.01 – identify the origins of various
religious beliefs regarding creation, birth, death, god, destiny, and
afterlife;
RB1.02 – identify the major influences in
the development of various religions (e.g., social unrest, advances in
technology, changing mores);
RB1.03 – identify influential
personalities (e.g., Abraham, Baha’ullah, Christ, Confucius, Dalai Lama, Guru
Nanak, Moses, Muhammad, Siddhartha Gautama, Zoroaster) and summarize their
contributions to the development of selected religions;
RB1.04 – evaluate the impact of key
concepts and events (e.g., ahimsa, resurrection, jihad, Pesach, fundamentalism,
revelation, salvation) on contemporary religions;
RB1.05 – demonstrate an understanding of
the development of the institutions that govern and promote the religious life
of a religion’s adherents (e.g., Sanhedrin, Universal House of Justice, Papacy,
Qadis).
Systems
of Belief
RB2.01 – identify common problems and
questions associated with the search for spiritual meaning;
RB2.02 – specify the responses of some
religions to these common problems and questions;
RB2.03 – demonstrate an understanding of
the concept of the supernatural in various belief systems (e.g., those of
Native peoples);
RB2.04 – describe the role of faith in
systems of belief;
RB2.05 – summarize the relationship
religious symbolism has to these systems of belief in various religions;
RB2.06 – identify significant sacred
writings and/or oral teachings from various religions;
RB2.07 – explore the origins and
development of sacred writings;
RB2.08 – compare and contrast the roles
sacred writings and oral teachings have in various religions;
RB2.09 – identify key principles from
relevant passages of sacred writings and oral teachings in various religions;
RB2.10 – examine the influence of sacred writings
and oral teachings from various religions on life in modern society.
Practices,
Rituals, Symbols, and Festivals
RB3.01 – categorize the practices and
rituals of various religions (e.g., adhan, almsgiving, asceticism, atonement,
anointing, covenant, sacrifice, holy days, dietary laws, vision quest);
RB3.02 – identify the origin and
significance of various practices, rituals, symbols, and festivals;
RB3.03 – demonstrate an understanding of
the role of sign and symbol in various religions.
SSV.01 · summarize the ways in which
religions and the development of civilizations are interconnected;
SSV.02 · analyse the influence of religion
on artistic expression;
SSV.03 · describe the influence that differing
gender-role expectations have had on the development of religion;
SSV.04 · demonstrate an understanding of
religious pluralism as a defining feature of contemporary Canadian society.
SS1.01 – review the political, economic, social,
ideological, or geographic impact of religion on at least one culture;
SS1.02 – demonstrate an understanding of
how religious beliefs influence the development of the policies and practices
of social institutions;
SS1.03 – describe the relationship of
religion and the state, and its historical transformation in specific cultures;
SS1.04 – identify ways in which symbolic
meaning is incorporated into civil practices that are commemorated in a solemn
fashion (e.g., through flags, the national anthem, observances on Remembrance
Day);
SS1.05 – identify ways in which religion
is reflected in specific works of art, architecture, music, literature, dance,
and in dress and cuisine, and interpret their religious significance;
SS1.06 – identify how and why different
religions express their beliefs through distinct cultural media;
SS1.07 – analyse the role of gender
stereotypes in the development of religious institutions and practices;
SS1.08 – identify the diverse religions
represented in Canada, and analyse how the high degree of religious pluralism
in the population is reflected in Canadian society and culture.
HEV.01 · identify the function of religion
in human experience;
HEV.02 · demonstrate an ability to
recognize prejudices associated with, and misconceptions about, various
religions, beliefs, and traditions;
HEV.03 · analyse the significance of
religion or other belief systems in the lives of various historical figures;
HEV.04 · speculate on the present and
future roles of religion.
Place
and Function of Religion in Human Experience
HE1.01 – identify the basic role and/or
responsibility of the individual adherents of a religion;
HE1.02 – demonstrate an understanding of a
variety of belief systems (e.g., secular humanism, materialism, agnosticism,
atheism);
HE1.03 – analyse demographic data to
predict the direction of religious change in contemporary society.
Prejudices
and Misconceptions
HE2.01 – identify religious leaders who used religion
to oppose prejudice and discrimination (e.g., Martin Luther King Jr., Mohandas
K. Gandhi, Marcus Garvey, Jesus Christ, Guru Nanak, Muhammad), and describe the
ways in which they did so;
HE2.02 – analyse attitudes, biases, and prejudices
held by adherents of various religions;
HE2.03 – analyse how positive and negative
attitudes within religious traditions have been used to justify local and
global prejudices and biases;
HE2.04 – demonstrate an understanding of differences
among traditional religions, sects, cults, and other types of religious
expression.
Significant
Figures
HE3.01 – identify significant figures from
a range of belief systems;
HE3.02 – describe how significant
individuals have been motivated by the belief systems studied to influence
events, create movements, and challenge the status quo of their day;
HE3.03 – demonstrate an understanding of
the characteristics, functions, and roles of selected religious leaders (e.g.,
reformer, civil activist, politician, founder, monastic, minister, missionary,
prophet, guru, liberator, diplomat).
Present
and Future Roles of Religion
HE4.01 – demonstrate an understanding of
the influence of religion on individuals in society;
HE4.02 – explain how the “religious impulse”
can be expressed outside formal religion;
HE4.03 – evaluate religion’s place in a
highly technological and scientific age;
HE4.04 – define the concept of civil
religion and give examples from various societies and eras.
ISV.01 · use appropriate theories and
analyses of religion in preparing an independent study;
ISV.02 · distinguish between fact and
opinion, belief and religion, and theory and practice, as they apply to the
study of religion;
ISV.03 · identify the implications of
different research methodologies in the study of religion;
ISV.04 · employ at least one of the
following research methodologies in an independent study: opinion survey,
demographic study, in-depth interview, database search, exploration of primary
sources;
ISV.05 · communicate the results of these
inquiries effectively;
ISV.06 · demonstrate effective
collaborative group skills.
Using
Research and Inquiry Skills
IS1.01 – identify problems in the study of
religion that require specific methods of quantitative and/or qualitative
research;
IS1.02 – compile a demographic study of
the various religions and traditions within their community, using personal
research methodologies (e.g., interviews, surveys) and/or Statistics Canada
data;
IS1.03 – conduct an in-depth interview,
using an appropriate interview format, with an individual who has dedicated his
or her life to a specific faith or belief system;
IS1.04 – explore and employ primary and
secondary research material appropriately in completing an assignment;
IS1.05 – demonstrate an ability to
organize, interpret, and evaluate the validity of information gathered through
research;
IS1.06 – use the Internet and other
available technologies as tools in researching topics in the study of religion,
and in establishing appropriate communication with people of different faiths,
as identified by the teacher.
Communicating
Results
IS2.01 – record information and key ideas from their research,
and document sources accurately, using correct forms of notation;
IS2.02 – effectively communicate the results of their
inquiries, using a variety of methods and forms (e.g., graphs, charts,
diagrams, oral presentations, written reports, essays, newspaper-style
articles, videos);
IS2.03 – defend a thesis, using
appropriate style, structure, argument, and documentation;
IS2.04 – use an appropriate research
format to investigate a socio-religious issue or problem, and present the methods,
results, discussion, and conclusion as part of a larger group assignment;
IS2.05 – use communications technology
appropriately to produce and disseminate the results of their research.